Manager Effectiveness – How to Support Leaders in an Era of Expanding Responsibilities

When managers are overwhelmed, business performance suffers. But across industries, leaders are asking managers to take on more—with less. Since 2017, average team sizes have tripled. Expectations have skyrocketed. And support from organizations hasn’t kept pace.

The result isn’t just stressed-out managers. It’s execution gaps, delayed decisions, and stalled progress on your most important initiatives. In fact, today’s managers are responsible for 51% more than they can effectively handle. Manager effectiveness is a make-or-break factor for organizational performance.

Why It’s Time to Rethink Manager Effectiveness 

Today’s managers sit at the intersection of strategy and execution—but most aren’t set up to succeed. Their role has evolved dramatically. They’re no longer just overseeing work. They’re coaching teams, translating vision into action, and driving outcomes in increasingly complex environments.

And yet, most manager support strategies haven’t kept pace, leaving leaders overwhelmed, teams underdeveloped, and performance on the line.

When managers are overloaded, everything slows down

Managers are being asked to do more than ever—but without the structure or tools to keep up. 

“Instead of thinking about burnout of managers, think about the situation they’re in,” says Anne Maltese, VP of People Insights at Quantum Workplace. “Are we teeing them up to be effective? Or are we creating hurdles they can’t overcome?”

The fallout is real:

• Coaching and career conversations take a back seat
• Performance check-ins become rushed or reactive
• Strategic priorities lose momentum

And as managers stretch to cover more ground, execution bottlenecks, missed decisions, and disengaged teams follow close behind.

Management is a capability, not just a job title

High performers are often rewarded with leadership roles—but few are equipped to lead. Nearly 4 in 10 managers have never received formal training, and only 36% of HR leaders say their programs prepare managers for the future.

Leadership today demands more than technical knowledge. Managers must navigate complex dynamics, coach in real time, and create psychological safety. And without the right support, even your best people can flounder in these roles. 

If we want better leaders, we need to build them—intentionally.

Your leadership pipeline is at risk  

The leadership crisis is already here. As experienced leaders retire and rising talent opts out, succession planning is becoming a strategic vulnerability. Only 23% of HR leaders feel confident they have future-ready leaders in place.

Worse still, 72% of Gen Z workers say they’d rather grow as individual contributors than take on management roles. And 1 in 5 managers would leave leadership if they had the option.

Why? Because the role feels broken—too administrative, too stressful, and too disconnected from meaningful work. To reverse this trend, organizations must make leadership a path worth pursuing again.

AI can be a turning point—if we use it right

AI isn’t replacing managers—it’s reimagining how they lead. When used well, AI eliminates administrative drag and frees managers to focus on high-impact work: coaching, developing, and delivering results.

Managers who effectively use technology are 3.4x more likely to be rated as strong leaders. But nearly half say their current tools don’t help them lead effectively. That’s a missed opportunity—and a competitive risk.

The future of work isn’t just digital. It’s human-centered and tech-enabled. And the organizations that invest in AI-powered tools—and empower managers to use them—will lead the way.

The Business Risk of Standing Still  

Weak manager support doesn’t just slow your teams. It slows your business. Without effective leaders, strategic initiatives stall, employee experience suffers, and long-term growth loses its footing.

Day-to-day strain turns into strategic drag

When managers are stretched thin, the impact ripples through every layer of the organization:

• Priorities become blurred
• Communication slows
• High performers don’t get the development they need

Teams operate in reactive mode. Decisions stall. And the connection between vision and execution starts to break down.

Burnout builds—and talent starts to walk

The human cost shows up fast:

Overloaded managers can’t deliver the leadership employees expect. Engagement drops. Frustration builds. And your best people start seeking growth elsewhere.

Long-term gaps threaten future growth

Manager ineffectiveness today becomes a pipeline problem tomorrow. Without the right training and support, future leaders don’t develop. Institutional knowledge walks out the door. And your organization becomes known for weak leadership development—a red flag for ambitious talent.

In an era where performance, agility, and engagement are make-or-break, manager effectiveness isn’t something organizations can afford to take lightly.

Best Practices for Building Manager Effectiveness at Scale

High-performing organizations don’t treat management as a reward for top performers—they treat it as a critical capability to build and sustain. They know that being great at the work isn’t the same as being great at leading people. That’s why forward-thinking HR leaders invest early, design intentionally, and enable managers with the tools, structure, and support to thrive. Here’s how they do it:

Plan ahead—way ahead

Great leadership doesn’t happen overnight. Leading organizations start developing managers two to three years before they step into formal leadership roles.

“Excelling in a role doesn’t automatically prepare someone to lead,” explains Julie Melidis, Director of Learning & Development at Benesch. “That’s why we don’t wait. Without preparation, the transition is a shock. Handing someone a team and saying, ‘Good luck,’ sets them up to fail.”

By starting early, organizations build confidence, close skill gaps, and ensure smoother transitions into leadership.

Redesign the role for scale and impact

To make manager effectiveness sustainable, organizations rethink the role itself. They eliminate low-value tasks—approvals, scheduling issues, administrative clutter—and reallocate that time toward what matters most: coaching, strategic decision-making, and people development. Automation, delegation, and clear boundaries help managers stay focused on the responsibilities only they can fulfill.

Use technology as a multiplier 

Technology doesn’t replace good leadership—it enables it. AI and automation can handle time-consuming tasks like data gathering, reporting, and workflow management, freeing managers to focus on their teams. When implemented thoughtfully, technology provides:

• Timely nudges and insights for coaching
• Feedback and goal-setting recommendations
• Real-time visibility into team progress
  
  

Treat succession planning as a shared responsibility

Leadership pipelines don’t build themselves. Leading HR teams partner closely with people managers to identify and develop future leaders early and intentionally. That includes:

• Data-driven systems for identifying high-potential talent
• Tools for assessing leadership readiness and skill gaps
• Stretch assignments, mentorship, and real-time coaching
  

“What’s missing is continuous coaching and support,” says Todd Pernicek, Senior Insights Analyst at Quantum Workplace. “Many companies offer one-time training, but leadership development isn’t a single event. It needs to be ongoing.”

These organizations embed leadership growth and succession planning into daily operations—not just classrooms—and build future-ready leaders from the ground up.

Five Manager Effectiveness Strategies You Can Implement This Quarter

You don’t need to overhaul everything at once to drive real change. By focusing on a few high-impact actions, you can start building stronger, more effective leaders—right now. These five strategies will help you create momentum this quarter while laying the groundwork for long-term leadership success.

Redesign the role to scale

Start with a workload audit to understand what’s consuming your managers’ time—and what shouldn’t be. Map daily activities into three categories:

• Tasks only managers can do (e.g., coaching, performance feedback)
• Tasks others can own (e.g., scheduling, admin)
• Tasks that can be automated (e.g., status reporting, approvals)

Then start clearing the path. Streamlining these tasks gives managers space to lead, not just react.

Build leadership as a continuous capability

Leadership isn’t a destination—it’s a skill to build over time. Create systems that provide:

• Ongoing coaching tied to real workplace challenges
• Peer groups where managers learn from one another
• Mentorship programs pairing emerging leaders with seasoned ones

Give managers access to resources, frameworks, and guidance—when they need it, not months later in a training binder.

Align on succession—before it’s urgent

Don’t wait until a key leader exits to think about who’s next.

• Define what great leadership looks like at your organization
• Use that model to assess current managers and surface high-potential talent
• Hold regular talent reviews where HR and managers collaborate on development plans and succession readiness

When HR and people leaders align, your leadership bench strengthens—by design, not default.

Use AI and technology to amplify managers

Choose one area where AI can remove busywork and enhance leadership impact. Start small—maybe it’s automating performance summaries, surfacing engagement insights, or tracking team development activity.

Well-designed tools don’t just save time—they sharpen judgment, guide more effective conversations, and help managers lead with clarity.

Most importantly, they equip managers to build thriving teams that are:

• Connected and engaged in their work, team, and organization
• Aligned and high-performing, with visibility into goals, progress, and obstacles
• Growing and future-ready, supported by clear development opportunities and coaching

When technology supports the human side of leadership, managers have the space—and the tools—to lead well.

Make manager enablement a business priority

If you want better leadership outcomes, manage them like you would any strategic initiative.

• Set clear metrics: team engagement, development activity, retention
• Secure executive sponsorship and model the behaviors you expect
• Report progress, share wins, and refine along the way

Manager effectiveness shouldn’t be an HR-only initiative—it’s a business-wide responsibility.

Want the Full Picture of 2025 Workplace Trends?

Access the complete strategic insights that forward-thinking HR leaders are using to build competitive advantage. The Workplace Trends Report delivers actionable intelligence across all seven game-changing areas.

Read the report now >>